Fresh herb sauces are less about following a rigid formula than balancing herbs, fat, acidity, salt, and texture.
Start with herbs and any nuts, seeds, garlic, or other flavorings called for in the recipe. Add olive oil gradually until the mixture loosens enough to spoon.
Taste before adding more of anything.
Acid should brighten the herbs without dominating them, while salt should make the individual flavors more distinct.
If the sauce becomes too thick, loosen it with additional olive oil or a small amount of water.
What to Look For
A loose herb sauce should:
fall easily from a spoon
retain visible texture
taste fresh rather than oily
have enough acidity to feel lively
Cook by Feel
The herbs themselves change from batch to batch. Tender spring herbs may need very little oil or acid, while stronger herbs can handle more.
Taste the sauce with the food you intend to serve it with rather than only from the spoon.